A Horrible Mother

A Horrible Mother

sad little girl in the car seat

By Holly Rizzuto Palker

Summer camp had just begun and it was the first hot day of the year. The air outside looked wavy. I strapped my child into her car seat and kissed her chubby cheeks. She was my third so I’d learned to take the time to do this. Often. Chelsea was impish and just shy of one-year. She looked up at me with wide eyes and giggled, “Mama.”

On average, 37 children die forgotten in cars each year in the U.S. from heat related deaths. As a 39-year-old stay at home mom of three in New Jersey, I felt constantly overwhelmed with tasks yet I never imagined I could forget my child.

We drove to pick up her older brother from day camp. The car was finally cooling from the air condition that circulated on high for the ten minutes it took us to get there. My mind spilled over with an endless to do list. Camp pickup was a change to our normal routine.

Though Chelsea was almost one, I’d barely slept the night before. I shouldn’t have run to her nursery the moment I heard her screaming but I couldn’t bear to hear her cry. She was my last and I was done Ferberizing. With this child I savored the comfortable feeling of a pudgy little body cuddled up next to me while sleeping. The problem was that once I brought her into my bed, I never fell back into a deep sleep fearing that she could be smothered under the blankets.

“I can do this,” I told myself. I believed I could handle three children with little sleep. Good mothers raised offspring, bought groceries, cooked dinner and kept the house without assistance. I was proud that I could handle it all by myself.

My cell phone rang in the car and it was my mom. She knew my life had been chaotic and my husband had been away for a few days on a work trip. She was aware I needed help since my best sitter was no longer working for me. Her voice switched over to blue tooth and filled my car.

“Do you need me?” she asked.

I glanced in the rearview to see if her tone was too loud for my Chelsea whose thighs folded over the straps at the meeting points of the car seat harness. Her mouth had fallen open, eyes closed she’d been swept away into napping bliss. I spied the rise and fall of her tummy underneath her flowery sundress.

We arrived at camp a few minutes late. I cringed because I knew my son despised being the last kid left anywhere.

“I’m good. I’ve gotta go,” I interrupted my mom who was listing time frames when she could come to New Jersey during the week. She ran her own business and was my grandmother’s caretaker. I didn’t want to burden her.

Watching the other moms walk with their kids swinging racquets on the way to their cars, I got out and locked the doors by remote. I rushed down the path to the camp. I was met with a woosh of ice cold air when I opened the door to the club house. My five-year-old son caught sight of me and ran toward my outstretched arms grabbing his belongings on the way. As I went in for the hug my mind replayed like in a movie when the twist becomes clear. I realized what I’d done. I dropped the racquet and my son’s things. I abandoned him and ran.

“Wait here. I’ll be right back,” I screamed. I waded through what felt like quicksand and I headed back to the car. How much time had passed? A minute? Maybe a few seconds more? Oh my God, how could I have left my little girl the back seat?

“Chelsea,” I yelled, my face bloated with tears. I flung open the door and unlocked the five-point harness, panting. She wasn’t moving. I shook her, assuming the worst. Had I suffocated my own child?

But then she opened her eyes and stared at me bewildered, a bit miffed for waking her so rudely.

I tore my baby from the car seat and ran back into the camp with her, shaky and lightheaded.

“I need water. I forgot her in the car,” I told a mom I knew, crying. Another mother rubbed my back to console me. The looks amongst the adults ranged from complete empathy to utter disgust. A 17 year-old counselor consoled me, “it was just a minute. Its okay.” Could she comprehend the implications of what I’d just done?

Someone brought my daughter a drink. My son looked on confused. Chelsea sipped the water as she sat on my lap, oblivious that I had just become a horrible mother.

I was embarrassed but I stayed for a few minutes, trying to regain my composure. I convinced everyone I was in good shape to drive home but I was unable to trust myself.

We entered the house and I turned on “Peppa Pig” for them to watch. I called my husband in Europe. He understood, and calmed me down.

Next I called my internist and retold the story. She was sympathetic too.

“How could I have done this?” I asked.

“This happens to parents more often than you can imagine. They don’t always remember quickly like you did.”

I kept crying.

“You’re exhausted, mentally stretched and still hormonal,” she answered.

“I’m not in my right mind,” I argued. I couldn’t accept that I made a mistake this severe. I convinced her to send me for testing to determine if I had some sort of cognitive dysfunction.

I heard a news feature about a man two months later who was being tried for murder because he “forgot” his child in a hot car and she died. I secretly sympathized with his defense because I believed how it might happen. Two of my relatives mentioned the story in disbelief. They couldn’t conceive of ever making a mistake so grave with their own children. I was afraid to tell them my story.

My tests came back negative for any mental impairments. From that day on, I drove with my purse by my toddler’s feet. I do this so I can’t leave the car without something I’m used to always holding. I check the back seat double and even triple times without a child in tow. I’ve finally forgiven myself and I thank God that I had the presence of mind to remember my child was in the car before it was too late. I’ve slowed down and stopped trying to be all things to all people. I swallow my pride and ask for a favor when I need it and If I’m late for camp pickup then so be it.

Holly is a freelance writer and novelist. She teaches drama to pre-school children and she is also raising three of her own dramatic children, a husband, and a dog. www.hollyrizzuto.com

Save

Save

In This Mom’s Car

In This Mom’s Car

carstuffIce scraper (1): Or two, depending on how you count. It’s in two pieces now, snapped in half during the most recent bout of foul weather. Now there’s the brush half and the scraper half and the one I can find is never the one I need.

Car seat (1): Not the most expensive model, but not the cheapest either. It’s nice, but not fancy, especially not now with its Pollock-esque décor of multicolored spit-up, hardened droplets of milk, and saliva-softened cheese crackers ground into the plush. But it’s safe; that’s the most important thing. It protects my child in a five-point hug while I move us from here to there and home again.

Stuffed elephant (1): It’s pink so he knows that it’s okay to love things that are soft and pink. Not everything has to be hard or firm or brown or blue. And when he doubts that, when he says it’s for girls, I’ll show him the pictures of his father holding him was a newborn. He loved you when you were soft and pink, I’ll say. Look. See for yourself.

Stroller (1): He prefers to walk, just not in the direction I’m trying to go. So sometimes it’s necessary to push him instead. When he’s tucked inside it, quiet and calm, I like to think it’s because he recognizes the speed of my walk, the rhythm of my gait from when he was tucked inside of me.

Diapers (2): Because running out of diapers is worse than running out of gas. I’d rather be stranded without food, without water, without phone or heat or hope of rescue. Because leaving the house without diapers is a mistake you only make once. Now there are two diapers, rolled as snugly as possible, crammed into my glove compartment next to my registration and under a pile of wadded napkins.

Window shades (4): Not on the windows, as you might expect. We’ve tried three different kinds, but can’t seem to get them to stay put. No, these are collapsed on the floor, puddles of tinted cling film and cheap suction cups. They’re no small source of guilt for me, the mom who isn’t protecting her baby’s precious skin.

Granola bars (5): Emergency breakfast for those mornings when he wants to be held so close it’s impossible to get a spoon to my mouth. Those days, I eat on the road on the way to library or the grocery store or music class. It’s a good trade, though, full arms for an empty stomach.

Socks (2): Two, but not a matching pair. In truth, we gave up “matching” a long time ago when it came to socks. Now we just pull two from the drawer and he wears them together, happily. The old women in line at the grocery store think it’s cute, and I smile and nod as if it is a fashion choice and not the result of total sock-matching exhaustion. But these two are such wildly different sizes, the same child could not wear both of them. I hold one in each hand, balanced on an outstretched palm: baby, toddler. How could my son have ever been so small? I think of my husband’s socks, which sometimes appear without explanation in my clean laundry. How could my son possibly ever get so big?

Cheerios (9): And those are just the ones I can see. There are others, no doubt, lurking between the seats, under the floor mats, caught in the sticky interior of the cup holder. The thing is, I can’t remember ever giving him Cheerios in the car. What is it about toddlers that allow them to spontaneously generate mess? My son, the alchemist, can already transform radio waves, sunlight, and clean air into cereal. Who knows what magic is next for him?

Illustrations by Christine Juneau